TMF Implementation Guide – Community Review

Comments Due By

 

We are pleased to announce that the TMF Standard Model Implementation Guide Version 1.0 Draft is now available for community review.

Community feedback will be accepted through January 8, 2027.

The Implementation Guide is a new type of resource for the TMF community, and its purpose is different from the TMF Standard Model itself. As you begin your review, we want to clarify what the guide is, how it should be used, and most importantly, the type of feedback we are seeking from the community at this stage.

 

What is the TMF Standard Model Implementation Guide?

The TMF Standard Model defines the standard itself, including the Zones, Record Groups, Record Types, Purpose/Descriptions, Unique Identifiers, metadata, and related attributes.

The Implementation Guide is the companion resource that provides the context needed to understand and apply those standard concepts consistently. It explains the concepts, design principles, assumptions, and implementation considerations that sit behind the model and provides guidance for organizations as they consider adoption and implementation.

The guide addresses topics such as:

  • The transition from the TMF Reference Model to the TMF Standard Model
  • The TMF Standard Model architecture, including Zones, Record Groups, Record Types, Unique Identifiers, metadata, levels, and record relationships
  • Principles for conformance to the TMF Standard Model

The Implementation Guide should be used alongside the Standard Model to understand the intent and context behind the concepts it defines.

TMF Implementation Guide v1.0 Draft

Implementation Feedback Form


 

How should the Implementation Guide support your review of the Standard Model?

We encourage you to use the Implementation Guide as a context-setting resource while reviewing the TMF Standard Model V1 Draft.

Many of the changes in V1 reflect a shift in how clinical trial evidence is defined, organized, and described. Concepts such as metadata usage, Unique Identifiers, the treatment of Communications and Notes to File, interoperability, and conformance are explained in greater detail in the guide.

If something in the Standard Model is unfamiliar or appears to represent a gap, please consult the relevant sections of the Implementation Guide before submitting feedback. The guide may provide additional context for why the model was designed in that way or how the concept is intended to be implemented.

 

What are we asking you to review?

The objective of this review is different from the community review of the Standard Model workbook. For the Implementation Guide, we are asking the community to focus on substantive gaps or missing information, rather than editorial refinement of the document.

As you review the guide, please consider:

  1. Does the guide provide sufficient context to understand the concepts, design principles, and intended application of the TMF Standard Model?
  2. Is there important information or implementation guidance missing that would significantly affect an organization's ability to understand, adopt, or implement the Standard Model?
  3. Are there substantive gaps or ambiguities that could result in materially different interpretations of the Standard Model?
  4. Are there significant implementation scenarios or considerations that should be addressed but are not currently represented?

     

What feedback are we not seeking?

At this stage, we are not seeking editorial comments on wording, sentence structure, formatting, stylistic preferences, or minor copyediting. The draft will undergo additional editorial review and refinement before publication.

Before submitting a comment, we encourage you to ask:

Would this issue materially affect someone's ability to understand or implement the TMF Standard Model?

If the answer is yes, we want to hear from you. If the suggestion would primarily improve wording or presentation without changing the meaning, completeness, or usability of the guidance, please do not submit it as part of this review.


 

How to provide useful feedback

For substantive comments, please:

  1. Identify the applicable section of the Implementation Guide.
  2. Clearly describe the gap, ambiguity, or missing information.
  3. Explain why the issue is important to understanding or implementing the TMF Standard Model.
  4. Where appropriate, provide a practical example, implementation scenario, or regulatory consideration that illustrates the concern.

Please submit your feedback using the Implementation Guide Community Feedback Form.

To help the working group review and address recommendations efficiently, please submit a separate form response for each suggested edit or substantive comment.

Specific, actionable feedback will help the development team determine whether the guide provides the context the community needs to understand and implement the Standard Model consistently.

The TMF Standard Model represents an important evolution for the TMF community, and the Implementation Guide is intended to help translate its concepts into a shared understanding of how the Standard can be applied in practice. Your expertise is critical to ensuring that the guide provides the right level of context and addresses the substantive questions organizations will encounter as they move toward implementation.

Thank you for your continued contribution to the CDISC TMF community and to the development of the TMF Standard Model.

Implementation Feedback Form